eved, while c… existing Marxist-Leninist states as well, most notably in the Zapatista Autonomous Municipalities. Left anti-communists however draw the “brave” claim of disavowing the most popular socialist movements in history while offering no alternative and very frequently endorsing no existing alternatives to these structures. I really don’t care if one supports China or not, nor do I care if one believes they have developed a new form of praxis that can build a better path to socialism. I particularly strongly encourage the latter. But if you hate China while having no alternative for how to achieve what China has achieved, while claiming to be a socialist of some kind, what exactly are you doing? What is your purpose as a socialist other than to undermine socialism in any form you can physicall…